Why Keira Knightley Is Unlikely to Return to Pirates of the Caribbean
Updated 18:33 5 Nov 2026 GMTPublished 17:52 3 Nov 2025 GMTA Pirates of the Caribbean reboot has already been confirmed to be in the works, and Depp could be back. Knightley however, won't be. The Pirates of the Caribbean films are set to be rebooted, with Johnny Depp having laid out his demands for a return, but despite Keira Knightley’s huge success since the movie she is very unlikely to appear as Elizabeth Swan again.Johnny Depp recently spoke about his demands for a return to Jack Sparrow, stating that he would only return if it was to send off his character on a better note than his last appearance.Depp has not played the character since Salazar’s Revenge, quite comfortably the worst film of the franchise.The actor also stated that he would be there no matter what if Jerry Bruckheimer asked, saying: “I will go to work with Bruckheimer tomorrow for anything. Doesn’t matter, if it’s Jerry, I trust him. We have a deep friendship.” It was previously confirmed that Bruckheimer is working on a reboot of the franchise, with multiple writers having turned in scripts. AdvertJohnny Depp may be set to come back in the previously announced reboot, but Knightley's return looks unlikely (Disney)Whilst Depp was the star of the Pirates films, earning himself an Oscar nomination in the process, Knightley and Orlando Bloom’s performances as Elizabeth Swann and Will Turner were key parts of the original trilogy, and the films after they departed were far weaker.Bloom has sounded incredibly up for a return in the past, but Knightley had some heartbreakingly negative words for her experience with the films.Over the years, Knightley has spoken out about being ‘taken down so publicly’ because of the legendary movies and how they also really rocketed her level of fame.Appearing as Swann at a young age from 2003 to 2007, the 40-year-old has already made her name in British films particularly before Pirates with Bend it Like Beckham and Love Actually.But her role in the Disney franchise truly granted her global recognition and yet while there are talks of a reprisal of the movies, Knightley’s over it.She starred as Swann in the first three Pirates films. (Disney)Speaking on BBC Radio 2 the star confessed to barely watching the work she’s appeared in even if she’s played some ‘great characters’.And so that includes having not really watched herself as Swann.“What’s wonderful about those films is they have become people's favourites and they watch them again and again and again and again,” she told Scott Mills.“I either haven’t watched them, or I have only watched them once, because it's not a particularly lovely experience watching your own face back at you.”As for Pirates, Knightley admitted: “I have never seen the third one. I saw the second one at the premiere, but I have never seen the third one.”The Pride & Prejudice star said she feels like there’s just ‘too much face’.“Really close up, large face,” she added. “It's just, nobody needs to see that.”Knightley previously said that she underwent ‘many years of therapy’ to help her manage the ‘level of scrutiny and that level of fame’ that came with the franchise.She reckons her 'pirating days are over'. (Swan Gallet/WWD via Getty Images)She once told The Telegraph: “The fame that came with them I just couldn’t handle.“So looking back, would I do anything different? No, I wouldn’t because I’m unbelievably lucky now, and my career is in a place where I really enjoy it, and I have a level of fame that’s much less intense."Knightley also added to The Times: “It's a funny thing when you have something that was making and breaking you at the same time."I was seen as s**t because of them, and yet because they did so well I was given the opportunity to do the films that I ended up getting Oscar nominations for.”She also told PEOPLE that she reckons her ‘pirating days are over’. The star explained: “I think I definitely spent many years doing that and, you know, it was amazing and I’m very pleased to have been a part of that, but I suspect that my swashbuckling days are done."Featured Image Credit: DisneyTopics: Celebrity, Disney, Entertainment, Film, TV and Film